England at the World Cup - who should be on the plane?
by Chris
Embarrassingly, England qualified for the World Cup with a dismal 1-0 victory over Slovenia, with the performance being one of the worst I've ever seen an England team do at Wembley. Slow, possession-based play trying to usurp the Barcelona of 08-09 is just impossible for this lacklustre England side with a seemingly disorganised manager with no distinct style or leaders. But, they've qualified, and no more can be asked of Southgate until Russia. But if they didn't, it would go down as an even worse failure than McLaren and the golden generation. This article will cover the 23 I would take if I was Southgate, on current form and injury preventing. Also, the ones who narrowly miss out on the squad, deservedly or undeservedly. I will also include a choice for permanent captain, and the pros and cons of England's squad and selection processes overall.
Goalkeepers:
1.Jack BUTLAND (Stoke City)
Age: 24
Caps: 5
Choice: #1 Goalkeeper
For many people, Joe Hart should be stuck with as England's number 1 because of past form, such as Mancini's triumph at City in 11-12 and Pellegrini's in 13-14, in which Hart was a mainstay in City's backline. But a sudden decline in form and confidence has led to him being loaned out to Torino and now West Ham United, where he has started poorly. Butland, however, after a long injury lay-off, has started this 17-18 season being as solid as before, and constantly asking questions of the current England number 1 whilst he isn't in form. I think Butland should be given a shot as number 1 'keeper next summer purely based on the poor performances of Hart in recent years at club level and internationally when under pressure. Of course, a player shouldn't become better whilst off the field, and if Butland does fail to prevail in an England shirt, Hart should be given the nod based on past performance.
2.Fraser FORSTER (Southampton F.C.)
Age: 29
Caps: 6
Choice: #2 Goalkeeper
I know, I'm controversial. But Fraser Forster's stats, and Southampton's defensive stats overall, cannot be ignored. The 6'7" goliath has kept 36 clean sheets in his 3 seasons at Southampton, more than Hart in his previous three seasons, and more than Thibaut Courtois and David de Gea, and baring in mind he's playing for a higher mid-table team rather than one competing for the title. This, for me, gives him the advantage over Hart as number 2. But with these impressive statistics, surely Forster would merit the number 1 spot? I think this could be possible, but with Butland's age, and potential, I believe it would be correct to nurture him into the tournament conditions if England were ever going further in the World Cup and European Championships.
3.Joe HART (West Ham United)
Age: 30
Caps: 74
Choice: #3 Goalkeeper
Believe me, I didn't want to even have him at number 3. But the previous performances for Manchester City 3/4 years ago is just enough for me to give faith to the Shrewsbury trainee. I would have selected Burnley 'keeper Tom Heaton, but for his injury and slight lack of form I've just headed with Hart. A Premier League winner, and England's most experienced player, it could be a good choice off the field. But is the experience even valid? Experienced in failure in England white, experienced in breezing through qualification and failing in big moments, so what is this experience, and what will it bring to the England camp? That's one to be discussed at a later time, but I'm sure my feelings are clear on the matter!
Right Backs:
4.Kyle WALKER (Manchester City)
Age: 27
Caps: 30
Choice: #1 Right Back
People rave about Walker as England's best right back. I for one disagree, as Clyne and Trippier offer better options defensively. But if Pep Guardiola thinks Kyle Walker can start in the City team, I'm not one to argue. He hasn't let down England as such, just his indifferent performances between a 5-6/10 just become frustrating as you want more from a player apparently worth £50m.
5.Kieran TRIPPIER (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 27
Caps: 2
Choice: #2 Right Back
Trippier's superb performances at the end of last season in the absence of the then first choice right back at Spurs Kyle Walker propelled him into Southgate's squad for the summer internationals. Although only starting 24 times in 3 seasons for Spurs, he showed excellent promise under Sean Dyche at Burnley, which tempted Pochettino into bringing him to Spurs, and his true potential can be reached this season if he can hold off the pressure of the Ivorian Serge Aurier, who was brought in for big money from Paris Saint-Germain. It remains to be seen whether he has the superiority over Nathaniel Clyne, but if he knuckles down and establishes himself finally in the first eleven at Spurs, he can maybe overtake Walker.
6.Nathaniel CLYNE (Liverpool F.C.)
Age: 26
Caps: 14
Choice: #3 Right Back, Left Back option
Because of the versatility of Clyne, he almost definitely will be on the plane regardless of form. His form of 15-16 and 16-17 have solidified his credentials as Jürgen Klopp's number 1 right back at Liverpool, even with the upcoming challenge of wonderkid Trent Alexander-Arnold. Although he has began the campaign injured, it is evident that he is very important with his balance of defensive and offensive credentials both to Liverpool and as cover for England.
Centre Backs:
7. Gary CAHILL (Chelsea F.C.)
Age: 31
Caps: 58 Goals: 4
Choice: Starting centre-back.
A steady member of England's line-up for 7 years now, we come to expect Cahill to be in the first eleven as a guarantee when we start our campaign in Russia next summer. He's not yet let England or Chelsea down in my opinion, and can be considered one of the most underrated centre-backs in the Premier League. He's clocked 325 Premier League appearances and his experience could be vital if there's the slightest spark of a chance that England could go far in this World Cup.
8. Phil JONES (Manchester United)
Age: 25
Caps: 23
Choice: Possible Starter
Although I'm no big admirer of the former Blackburn man, there's no denying that his form has improved over the past 6 months and Jose Mourinho has appeared to have extracted the best out of Jones, who arrived for £16m back in 2011. In his Premier League career, he has completed 73% of tackles, which reflects less than compatriots Cahill, Keane, and Maguire, but baring in mind he's playing in a side which gets attacked less so therefore he'd be better measured on footballing stats such as passing, which he completes more per match than the latter three with an average of around 38 a game. He's clearly improved and why not start him, but only at the expense of the man below.
9. John STONES (Manchester City)
Age: 23
Caps: 20
Choice: Possible Starter
Jones's starting place, in my opinion, depends on the form of this man. Apparent potential has been lauded on the former Barnsley and Everton defender as if he has already achieved all of his goals and ambitions within football, which is strange for a player who is sometimes mediocre and frustrating. Everton fans in the 2015/16 season were publicly dissenting of Stones's style of defending, which in a nutshell they considered risky, and the video of Stones descending his hands in attempt to calm Everton fans' complaints became a much used clip in Stones' criticism. But this didn't stop Pep Guardiola forking out £50 million for the defender, and this season he's showed some improvement even if limited. He's obviously got potential to be better than it is, but in my view, it is not sky-high which some people believe it is.
10. Michael KEANE (Everton F.C.)
Age: 24
Caps: 4
Choice: Backup
Keane last season became one of the most sought-after centre-backs in the Premier League, with Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal and Manchester City all hunting the ex-United trainee. But he chose Koeman's Evertonian revolution as his preferred destination, and thus far, it seems like a good one. Although Everton's form has dipped and naturally, so has Keane's, his regular football is something which may not have come by at the so-called bigger clubs, and his development will surely be aided by these regular minutes. Maybe by 2022, he will be England's starting centre-back and be a mainstay in a top 6 defence, but of course it's too soon to say for the PFA Young Player of the Year nominee.
Left Backs: (Clyne not included)
11: Ryan BERTRAND (Southampton F.C.)
Age: 28
Caps: 17 Goals: 1
Choice: #1 Left Back
Ryan Bertrand had a rollercoaster career before joining Southampton back in 2014. Loan moves to 6 different clubs in 7 years from Chelsea, where he was forever held back by top full-back Ashley Cole, must have delayed development and eventually may have ended potential to be an England left back for years before this and years to come, but he's finally found some consistency at the Saints and settled under Koeman, Puel and Pellegrino to become a crucial first team member. Although his form for England is very inconsistent, his club form merits him to be the starting left back in Russia.
12: Aaron CRESSWELL (West Ham United)
Age: 27
Caps: 3
Choice: #2 Left Back
Aaron Cresswell's rise through the footballing ranks is one to inspire any. After beginning his pro career at Tranmere Rovers, he has played under Ipswich for Mick McCarthy, and his form at Portman Road convinced the Irons to spend up to £4m on him. He has since become a regular under Slaven Bilic fending off competition from Frenchman Arthur Masuaku. Although he's talented, I'm not sure he's got the versatility of Bertrand offensively and defensively. I feel Bertrand just about offers more defensively than Cresswell because of his well-drilled Southampton roots, and that's the only reason why I would edge towards the former Chelsea man.
Central and Defensive Midfielders:
13: Jordan HENDERSON (Liverpool F.C.) (C)
Age: 27
Caps: 36
Choice: Starting midfielder
Jordan Henderson has been arguably England's best player since the injury to Adam Lallana has ruled him out of the recent qualifiers. Although his slow form of playing sometimes frustrates and annoys Liverpool supporters, this style is absolutely perfect for the type of football Southgate is currently breeding in the England camp. His form has improved recently for Liverpool too, and this is why he must start in Russia.
I've also selected Henderson as England captain for next summer's tournament. Why not Kane? Why nor Cahill? Well, Kane isn't even the captain of his club, so why should he take on the mantel of captaining his country if he has hardly any experience. There's no denying his leadership skills or the quality of player, but he is not captain of his club. If International football is supposedly a step up from club football, why should he be given that honour with limited experience. Cahill would be the only other contender I would consider, but I would just shade Henderson because of his longevity option. He could captain at possibly 3 more major tournaments after next summer, and this may be Cahill's last or penultimate tournament.
14: Eric DIER (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 23
Caps: 21 Goals: 3
Choice: Possible starter, depending on formation
Eric Dier famously hit a fantastic free kick to give England's first goal of Euro 2016 against Russia, and his previous two seasons for Spurs have on paper been excellent. But his performances, like Henderson, can be tedious and frustrating for Spurs and England fans. Although sometimes very ponderous in possession, Dier completes an average of 54 passes per game, more than any other Spurs player barring Jan Vertonghen. Dier's place in the starting XI depends on which formation Southgate chooses to operate. If he chooses to play 2 defensive midfielders, one expects him to go with Henderson and Dier. If not, one or the other, but Henderson is very coveted by Southgate and I'm 100% sure he will play.
15: Adam LALLANA (Liverpool F.C.)
Age: 29
Caps: 33 Goals: 3
Choice: Starting central midfielder
Adam Lallana's rise under Jürgen Klopp at Liverpool is one of the Germans best accomplishments, turning a fringe player into a key man in their Champions League qualification last season. He was also England's player of the year in 2016, which underlines his tremendous improvement. An injury in pre-season has halted his start to this season until November, and this has proved further his importance to a slightly faltering Liverpool side. He most definitely is integral for England at any faint hope or chance of finishing victorious in Russia.
16: Dele ALLI (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 21
Caps: 22 Goals: 2
Choice: Starter
Dele Alli is truly one of football's global wonderkids, bagging 30 Premier League goals in just 77 appearances for Spurs. His failure thus far to recreate his Tottenham form for the Three Lions is most definitely a concern however, for he has the talent and ability to win games on his own for England. His partnership and linkage with teammate Harry Kane could be a factor in whether England score any goals at the World cup next year. Kane and Alli have been directly involved in 107 goals in the two previous seasons and the beginning of this season, totalling 63% of all Tottenham goals. If these two can usurp their Tottenham form for England, we could be a real force come Russia, but the likelihood of that happening, well, close to zero in my opinion. The style of football is just not suited to some of England's most key players, and unless that is sorted before the big day, another failure at a big tournament is on the cards for England.
Raheem Sterling certainly divides opinion, but his recent form of the past two seasons cannot be ignored. Has he ever commanded the £49m Manchester City forked out for him back in 2015? Well, certainly over the past two months has portrayed his class and guile even at the tender age of 22. He's scored 6 goals in 9 games as Manchester City have stormed to the top of the Premier League table, forming excellent connections with the likes of Kevin de Bruyne and Gabriel Jesus. Even though he has already scored 37 Premier League goals, his evolution must come in clinical finishing of chances and becoming a 15-20 goal-a-season winger, which he certainly has the potential to do, especially under Pep Guardiola.
Caps: 36 Goals: 15
Choice: Backup
There's several men who I could've edged towards for the third striker position, but the former United man has never let England down yet. His goals-to-game ratio is one which is only bettered by Kane in this squad, and his way of playing differs to the likes of Vardy and Kane. If I'd have gone for Defoe, his style is quite similar to Vardy's, likewise with Kane and Andy Carroll. Welbeck brings the two together, with a large stride and good pace partnered with great strength and power. His stats don't look as good as the Vardy's and Kane's, as he's only scored 39 Premier League goals in 176 appearances, but his contribution off the ball is not one to be ignored when selecting the squad.
So the squad is complete, but what sort of piece would this be if I didn't include some of the 'nearly men' for decision justification. Here are some names and brief summaries of players who were in deep consideration for me and might be for Gareth Southgate, but didn't quite make it for me.
Tom Heaton (Burnley)
The Burnley man has been rock solid for Burnley since their return to the Premier League, and has been essential for Sean Dyche in all plans. Although he's had an injury-stricken start to 2017-18 and been ably replaced by ex-Charlton man Nick Pope, Heaton will always be number 1. Unfortunately for England there are 4 quality 'keepers vying for one spot. Although for me I would have Heaton over Hart, I'm sure Gareth Southgate will pick the West Ham man on past form.
Harry Maguire (Leicester City)
Maguire hasn't had the greatest Premier League career in terms of positioning, being relegated twice with Hull City and currently sitting in the relegation zone with Leicester City. But his performances last season and this season have been very contradictory to where his teams have been in the Premier League, and that has seen him handed an England debut in Vilnius against Lithuania. He just hasn't got the quality of Jones and Stones which I think will be the starting partnership come next summer.
Harry Winks (Tottenham Hotspur)
Also given a debut in Vilnius, Harry Winks is Spurs' next big prodigy and is featuring more and more in the current first team. Is it too early for a big tournament? For me, just about. He needs to become established in the first eleven and then perform at a decent level to then be considered seriously for a major tournament.
Michail Antonio (West Ham United)
This was for me the toughest decision in the toss-up between Lingard and Antonio. I just edged towards Lingard due to his youth and his experience playing at high level European football. Antonio may well be selected because of his versatility, pace and skill, and I would most definitely not begrudge him of such an honour, but for me, just Lingard.
Jermain Defoe (A.F.C Bournemouth)
The wily 35 year old striker has the fitness and ability of an in-prime 27 year old, but his form of late just slots him behind Danny Welbeck in my opinion. Although a clinical finisher and extremely talented, he is getting on a little and this must be his last chance to play in a major tournament. If he scores 15 goals for Bournemouth this season I would definitely take him above Welbeck but I just think Welbeck brings something different to the other two strikers.
Daniel Sturridge (Liverpool F.C.)
Many people would take Daniel Sturridge above Welbeck and Vardy on his form of Liverpool's thrilling title attempt of 2013/14. But the typical Sturridge generalisations saying that he has quick pace and clinical finishing ability are, in my opinion, total myths. He hasn't shown any noticeably quick pace since that miraculous season, and his conversion rate has declined in serious force. Not only this, but his injury record is not one to be proud of either. Generally speaking, he's one not to get too excited about because he will just let you down, and I speak from experience. It's such a shame because for a man of such talent to be tossed off is an extreme disappointment, but it's just realism. He's had enough chances to stamp down his fitness and form and for me, this is the final straw.
I hope you enjoyed this, as it's taken over a week's effort for me to complete, and any informed views and criticism is extremely welcome in the comments!
Embarrassingly, England qualified for the World Cup with a dismal 1-0 victory over Slovenia, with the performance being one of the worst I've ever seen an England team do at Wembley. Slow, possession-based play trying to usurp the Barcelona of 08-09 is just impossible for this lacklustre England side with a seemingly disorganised manager with no distinct style or leaders. But, they've qualified, and no more can be asked of Southgate until Russia. But if they didn't, it would go down as an even worse failure than McLaren and the golden generation. This article will cover the 23 I would take if I was Southgate, on current form and injury preventing. Also, the ones who narrowly miss out on the squad, deservedly or undeservedly. I will also include a choice for permanent captain, and the pros and cons of England's squad and selection processes overall.
Goalkeepers:
1.Jack BUTLAND (Stoke City)
Age: 24
Caps: 5
Choice: #1 Goalkeeper
For many people, Joe Hart should be stuck with as England's number 1 because of past form, such as Mancini's triumph at City in 11-12 and Pellegrini's in 13-14, in which Hart was a mainstay in City's backline. But a sudden decline in form and confidence has led to him being loaned out to Torino and now West Ham United, where he has started poorly. Butland, however, after a long injury lay-off, has started this 17-18 season being as solid as before, and constantly asking questions of the current England number 1 whilst he isn't in form. I think Butland should be given a shot as number 1 'keeper next summer purely based on the poor performances of Hart in recent years at club level and internationally when under pressure. Of course, a player shouldn't become better whilst off the field, and if Butland does fail to prevail in an England shirt, Hart should be given the nod based on past performance.
2.Fraser FORSTER (Southampton F.C.)
Age: 29
Caps: 6
Choice: #2 Goalkeeper
I know, I'm controversial. But Fraser Forster's stats, and Southampton's defensive stats overall, cannot be ignored. The 6'7" goliath has kept 36 clean sheets in his 3 seasons at Southampton, more than Hart in his previous three seasons, and more than Thibaut Courtois and David de Gea, and baring in mind he's playing for a higher mid-table team rather than one competing for the title. This, for me, gives him the advantage over Hart as number 2. But with these impressive statistics, surely Forster would merit the number 1 spot? I think this could be possible, but with Butland's age, and potential, I believe it would be correct to nurture him into the tournament conditions if England were ever going further in the World Cup and European Championships.
3.Joe HART (West Ham United)
Age: 30
Caps: 74
Choice: #3 Goalkeeper
Believe me, I didn't want to even have him at number 3. But the previous performances for Manchester City 3/4 years ago is just enough for me to give faith to the Shrewsbury trainee. I would have selected Burnley 'keeper Tom Heaton, but for his injury and slight lack of form I've just headed with Hart. A Premier League winner, and England's most experienced player, it could be a good choice off the field. But is the experience even valid? Experienced in failure in England white, experienced in breezing through qualification and failing in big moments, so what is this experience, and what will it bring to the England camp? That's one to be discussed at a later time, but I'm sure my feelings are clear on the matter!
Right Backs:
4.Kyle WALKER (Manchester City)
Age: 27
Caps: 30
Choice: #1 Right Back
People rave about Walker as England's best right back. I for one disagree, as Clyne and Trippier offer better options defensively. But if Pep Guardiola thinks Kyle Walker can start in the City team, I'm not one to argue. He hasn't let down England as such, just his indifferent performances between a 5-6/10 just become frustrating as you want more from a player apparently worth £50m.
5.Kieran TRIPPIER (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 27
Caps: 2
Choice: #2 Right Back
Trippier's superb performances at the end of last season in the absence of the then first choice right back at Spurs Kyle Walker propelled him into Southgate's squad for the summer internationals. Although only starting 24 times in 3 seasons for Spurs, he showed excellent promise under Sean Dyche at Burnley, which tempted Pochettino into bringing him to Spurs, and his true potential can be reached this season if he can hold off the pressure of the Ivorian Serge Aurier, who was brought in for big money from Paris Saint-Germain. It remains to be seen whether he has the superiority over Nathaniel Clyne, but if he knuckles down and establishes himself finally in the first eleven at Spurs, he can maybe overtake Walker.
6.Nathaniel CLYNE (Liverpool F.C.)
Age: 26
Caps: 14
Choice: #3 Right Back, Left Back option
Because of the versatility of Clyne, he almost definitely will be on the plane regardless of form. His form of 15-16 and 16-17 have solidified his credentials as Jürgen Klopp's number 1 right back at Liverpool, even with the upcoming challenge of wonderkid Trent Alexander-Arnold. Although he has began the campaign injured, it is evident that he is very important with his balance of defensive and offensive credentials both to Liverpool and as cover for England.
Centre Backs:
7. Gary CAHILL (Chelsea F.C.)
Age: 31
Caps: 58 Goals: 4
Choice: Starting centre-back.
A steady member of England's line-up for 7 years now, we come to expect Cahill to be in the first eleven as a guarantee when we start our campaign in Russia next summer. He's not yet let England or Chelsea down in my opinion, and can be considered one of the most underrated centre-backs in the Premier League. He's clocked 325 Premier League appearances and his experience could be vital if there's the slightest spark of a chance that England could go far in this World Cup.
8. Phil JONES (Manchester United)
Age: 25
Caps: 23
Choice: Possible Starter
Although I'm no big admirer of the former Blackburn man, there's no denying that his form has improved over the past 6 months and Jose Mourinho has appeared to have extracted the best out of Jones, who arrived for £16m back in 2011. In his Premier League career, he has completed 73% of tackles, which reflects less than compatriots Cahill, Keane, and Maguire, but baring in mind he's playing in a side which gets attacked less so therefore he'd be better measured on footballing stats such as passing, which he completes more per match than the latter three with an average of around 38 a game. He's clearly improved and why not start him, but only at the expense of the man below.
9. John STONES (Manchester City)
Age: 23
Caps: 20
Choice: Possible Starter
Jones's starting place, in my opinion, depends on the form of this man. Apparent potential has been lauded on the former Barnsley and Everton defender as if he has already achieved all of his goals and ambitions within football, which is strange for a player who is sometimes mediocre and frustrating. Everton fans in the 2015/16 season were publicly dissenting of Stones's style of defending, which in a nutshell they considered risky, and the video of Stones descending his hands in attempt to calm Everton fans' complaints became a much used clip in Stones' criticism. But this didn't stop Pep Guardiola forking out £50 million for the defender, and this season he's showed some improvement even if limited. He's obviously got potential to be better than it is, but in my view, it is not sky-high which some people believe it is.
10. Michael KEANE (Everton F.C.)
Age: 24
Caps: 4
Choice: Backup
Keane last season became one of the most sought-after centre-backs in the Premier League, with Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal and Manchester City all hunting the ex-United trainee. But he chose Koeman's Evertonian revolution as his preferred destination, and thus far, it seems like a good one. Although Everton's form has dipped and naturally, so has Keane's, his regular football is something which may not have come by at the so-called bigger clubs, and his development will surely be aided by these regular minutes. Maybe by 2022, he will be England's starting centre-back and be a mainstay in a top 6 defence, but of course it's too soon to say for the PFA Young Player of the Year nominee.
Left Backs: (Clyne not included)
11: Ryan BERTRAND (Southampton F.C.)
Age: 28
Caps: 17 Goals: 1
Choice: #1 Left Back
Ryan Bertrand had a rollercoaster career before joining Southampton back in 2014. Loan moves to 6 different clubs in 7 years from Chelsea, where he was forever held back by top full-back Ashley Cole, must have delayed development and eventually may have ended potential to be an England left back for years before this and years to come, but he's finally found some consistency at the Saints and settled under Koeman, Puel and Pellegrino to become a crucial first team member. Although his form for England is very inconsistent, his club form merits him to be the starting left back in Russia.
12: Aaron CRESSWELL (West Ham United)
Age: 27
Caps: 3
Choice: #2 Left Back
Aaron Cresswell's rise through the footballing ranks is one to inspire any. After beginning his pro career at Tranmere Rovers, he has played under Ipswich for Mick McCarthy, and his form at Portman Road convinced the Irons to spend up to £4m on him. He has since become a regular under Slaven Bilic fending off competition from Frenchman Arthur Masuaku. Although he's talented, I'm not sure he's got the versatility of Bertrand offensively and defensively. I feel Bertrand just about offers more defensively than Cresswell because of his well-drilled Southampton roots, and that's the only reason why I would edge towards the former Chelsea man.
Central and Defensive Midfielders:
13: Jordan HENDERSON (Liverpool F.C.) (C)
Age: 27
Caps: 36
Choice: Starting midfielder
Jordan Henderson has been arguably England's best player since the injury to Adam Lallana has ruled him out of the recent qualifiers. Although his slow form of playing sometimes frustrates and annoys Liverpool supporters, this style is absolutely perfect for the type of football Southgate is currently breeding in the England camp. His form has improved recently for Liverpool too, and this is why he must start in Russia.
I've also selected Henderson as England captain for next summer's tournament. Why not Kane? Why nor Cahill? Well, Kane isn't even the captain of his club, so why should he take on the mantel of captaining his country if he has hardly any experience. There's no denying his leadership skills or the quality of player, but he is not captain of his club. If International football is supposedly a step up from club football, why should he be given that honour with limited experience. Cahill would be the only other contender I would consider, but I would just shade Henderson because of his longevity option. He could captain at possibly 3 more major tournaments after next summer, and this may be Cahill's last or penultimate tournament.
14: Eric DIER (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 23
Caps: 21 Goals: 3
Choice: Possible starter, depending on formation
Eric Dier famously hit a fantastic free kick to give England's first goal of Euro 2016 against Russia, and his previous two seasons for Spurs have on paper been excellent. But his performances, like Henderson, can be tedious and frustrating for Spurs and England fans. Although sometimes very ponderous in possession, Dier completes an average of 54 passes per game, more than any other Spurs player barring Jan Vertonghen. Dier's place in the starting XI depends on which formation Southgate chooses to operate. If he chooses to play 2 defensive midfielders, one expects him to go with Henderson and Dier. If not, one or the other, but Henderson is very coveted by Southgate and I'm 100% sure he will play.
15: Adam LALLANA (Liverpool F.C.)
Age: 29
Caps: 33 Goals: 3
Choice: Starting central midfielder
Adam Lallana's rise under Jürgen Klopp at Liverpool is one of the Germans best accomplishments, turning a fringe player into a key man in their Champions League qualification last season. He was also England's player of the year in 2016, which underlines his tremendous improvement. An injury in pre-season has halted his start to this season until November, and this has proved further his importance to a slightly faltering Liverpool side. He most definitely is integral for England at any faint hope or chance of finishing victorious in Russia.
16: Dele ALLI (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 21
Caps: 22 Goals: 2
Choice: Starter
Dele Alli is truly one of football's global wonderkids, bagging 30 Premier League goals in just 77 appearances for Spurs. His failure thus far to recreate his Tottenham form for the Three Lions is most definitely a concern however, for he has the talent and ability to win games on his own for England. His partnership and linkage with teammate Harry Kane could be a factor in whether England score any goals at the World cup next year. Kane and Alli have been directly involved in 107 goals in the two previous seasons and the beginning of this season, totalling 63% of all Tottenham goals. If these two can usurp their Tottenham form for England, we could be a real force come Russia, but the likelihood of that happening, well, close to zero in my opinion. The style of football is just not suited to some of England's most key players, and unless that is sorted before the big day, another failure at a big tournament is on the cards for England.
17: Alex OXLADE-CHAMBERLAIN (Liverpool F.C.)
Age: 24
Caps: 30 Goals: 6
Choice: Possible
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain is and has been a good performer for England over the past 5 years. His style is more suited to the Hodgson/Southgate mould and is very versatile. I've put him under central midfield, but he could feature at right wing-back, attacking midfield or even in a false-nine role, and that's why he's such a key player for England. He is the perfect substitute for both Liverpool and England in my opinion, for all situations. If they need a goal, they can send him on as an attacking option. If they need to consolidate, they could send him on centrally as a faster option with fresher legs. Or if they need to switch to 3 at the back, they can send 'the Ox' on to be the energised wing back on right or left.
Age: 24
Caps: 30 Goals: 6
Choice: Possible
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain is and has been a good performer for England over the past 5 years. His style is more suited to the Hodgson/Southgate mould and is very versatile. I've put him under central midfield, but he could feature at right wing-back, attacking midfield or even in a false-nine role, and that's why he's such a key player for England. He is the perfect substitute for both Liverpool and England in my opinion, for all situations. If they need a goal, they can send him on as an attacking option. If they need to consolidate, they could send him on centrally as a faster option with fresher legs. Or if they need to switch to 3 at the back, they can send 'the Ox' on to be the energised wing back on right or left.
Attacking Midfielders and Strikers:
18: Raheem STERLING (Manchester City)
Age: 22
Caps: 35 Goals: 2
Choice: Starter
19. Marcus RASHFORD (Manchester United)
Age: 19
Caps: 13 Goals: 2
Choice: Possible Starter
Marcus Rashford's rise to glory is still very much in construction but the early signs of promise are extremely exciting for both Manchester United and England supporters. His lightning-quick darts at defences are sometimes devastating and can win a game by himself. But the consistency is yet to be established at both club and international level and that acts as a constant reminder for fans of his age and inexperience. But Southgate is known to be a great promoter of youth development on the international stage and this might be why Rashford may start either on the wing or up front. There is no doubting his quality, but whether he can cut it at a major tournament is yet to be seen. His nascence is unignorably persistent though, and I cannot wait to see what future holds for Marcus Rashford.
20: Jesse LINGARD (Manchester United)
Age: 19
Caps: 13 Goals: 2
Choice: Possible Starter
Marcus Rashford's rise to glory is still very much in construction but the early signs of promise are extremely exciting for both Manchester United and England supporters. His lightning-quick darts at defences are sometimes devastating and can win a game by himself. But the consistency is yet to be established at both club and international level and that acts as a constant reminder for fans of his age and inexperience. But Southgate is known to be a great promoter of youth development on the international stage and this might be why Rashford may start either on the wing or up front. There is no doubting his quality, but whether he can cut it at a major tournament is yet to be seen. His nascence is unignorably persistent though, and I cannot wait to see what future holds for Marcus Rashford.
20: Jesse LINGARD (Manchester United)
Age: 24
Caps: 6
Choice: Backup
Jesse Lingard isn't of the same class as Rashford, and has significantly less potential. Yes, it seems rather blunt, but that is why he mainly comes off the bench for England and United. Yes, he doesn't have the marquee name of a Pogba, a Lukaku or an Ibrahimović, but his effort, desire and pace do bring something different to United and occasionally give them an added boost in a certain game. Gareth Southgate gave the Mancunian his debut for England, and I think his admiration of Lingard will put him on the plane to Russia. His raw effort will be always admired, but whether that makes him better than the likes of Rashford remains to be seen.
21: Harry KANE (Tottenham Hotspur)
Caps: 6
Choice: Backup
Jesse Lingard isn't of the same class as Rashford, and has significantly less potential. Yes, it seems rather blunt, but that is why he mainly comes off the bench for England and United. Yes, he doesn't have the marquee name of a Pogba, a Lukaku or an Ibrahimović, but his effort, desire and pace do bring something different to United and occasionally give them an added boost in a certain game. Gareth Southgate gave the Mancunian his debut for England, and I think his admiration of Lingard will put him on the plane to Russia. His raw effort will be always admired, but whether that makes him better than the likes of Rashford remains to be seen.
21: Harry KANE (Tottenham Hotspur)
Age: 24
Caps: 23 Goals: 12
Choice: Starter
Harry Kane is absolutely crucial to any faint hope England have of doing well at this World Cup. Simply put, he defies and has defied almost everybody's opinion of him since he broke through in 2014. "One season wonder" they said, as Kane beat his total goals from the previous season, and then again in 16/17, where he finished as Golden boot winner once again. He may not have the natural talent of players such as Rooney, Lineker, Owen or Fowler, but his improvement on all technical and physical areas have most certainly made up for that. He already has scored 84 Premier league goals, in just 120 games, including six hat-tricks alone in 2017 so far, and is just as important for Spurs as he is for England. Although his performances have been lesser for England than for Tottenham, if he can replicate, England will most definitely go far in this tournament. Like Alli though, the likelihood of this is, well, very low to say the least. England, bluntly, will not gel. It is down to individuality whether England go far or not.
22: Jamie VARDY (Leicester City)
Age: 30
Caps: 17 Goals: 6
Choice: Backup
It's hard to talk about Jamie Vardy and not talk about the title winning season and how he raised his game for that miracle. But the underlying fact is, his quality and never-say-die attitude bring England a different edge to what they did before. He has portrayed his fabulous skills at levels ranging from Stocksbridge Park Steels and the non-league to being linked with Arsenal and a Premier League star. It's football's biggest romantic story and will forever be repeated, but one cannot deny his 'rough diamond' image is one which can inspire England to a possible result.
23: Danny WELBECK (Arsenal F.C.)
Age: 26Caps: 23 Goals: 12
Choice: Starter
Harry Kane is absolutely crucial to any faint hope England have of doing well at this World Cup. Simply put, he defies and has defied almost everybody's opinion of him since he broke through in 2014. "One season wonder" they said, as Kane beat his total goals from the previous season, and then again in 16/17, where he finished as Golden boot winner once again. He may not have the natural talent of players such as Rooney, Lineker, Owen or Fowler, but his improvement on all technical and physical areas have most certainly made up for that. He already has scored 84 Premier league goals, in just 120 games, including six hat-tricks alone in 2017 so far, and is just as important for Spurs as he is for England. Although his performances have been lesser for England than for Tottenham, if he can replicate, England will most definitely go far in this tournament. Like Alli though, the likelihood of this is, well, very low to say the least. England, bluntly, will not gel. It is down to individuality whether England go far or not.
22: Jamie VARDY (Leicester City)
Age: 30
Caps: 17 Goals: 6
Choice: Backup
It's hard to talk about Jamie Vardy and not talk about the title winning season and how he raised his game for that miracle. But the underlying fact is, his quality and never-say-die attitude bring England a different edge to what they did before. He has portrayed his fabulous skills at levels ranging from Stocksbridge Park Steels and the non-league to being linked with Arsenal and a Premier League star. It's football's biggest romantic story and will forever be repeated, but one cannot deny his 'rough diamond' image is one which can inspire England to a possible result.
23: Danny WELBECK (Arsenal F.C.)
Caps: 36 Goals: 15
Choice: Backup
There's several men who I could've edged towards for the third striker position, but the former United man has never let England down yet. His goals-to-game ratio is one which is only bettered by Kane in this squad, and his way of playing differs to the likes of Vardy and Kane. If I'd have gone for Defoe, his style is quite similar to Vardy's, likewise with Kane and Andy Carroll. Welbeck brings the two together, with a large stride and good pace partnered with great strength and power. His stats don't look as good as the Vardy's and Kane's, as he's only scored 39 Premier League goals in 176 appearances, but his contribution off the ball is not one to be ignored when selecting the squad.
So the squad is complete, but what sort of piece would this be if I didn't include some of the 'nearly men' for decision justification. Here are some names and brief summaries of players who were in deep consideration for me and might be for Gareth Southgate, but didn't quite make it for me.
Tom Heaton (Burnley)
The Burnley man has been rock solid for Burnley since their return to the Premier League, and has been essential for Sean Dyche in all plans. Although he's had an injury-stricken start to 2017-18 and been ably replaced by ex-Charlton man Nick Pope, Heaton will always be number 1. Unfortunately for England there are 4 quality 'keepers vying for one spot. Although for me I would have Heaton over Hart, I'm sure Gareth Southgate will pick the West Ham man on past form.
Harry Maguire (Leicester City)
Maguire hasn't had the greatest Premier League career in terms of positioning, being relegated twice with Hull City and currently sitting in the relegation zone with Leicester City. But his performances last season and this season have been very contradictory to where his teams have been in the Premier League, and that has seen him handed an England debut in Vilnius against Lithuania. He just hasn't got the quality of Jones and Stones which I think will be the starting partnership come next summer.
Harry Winks (Tottenham Hotspur)
Also given a debut in Vilnius, Harry Winks is Spurs' next big prodigy and is featuring more and more in the current first team. Is it too early for a big tournament? For me, just about. He needs to become established in the first eleven and then perform at a decent level to then be considered seriously for a major tournament.
Michail Antonio (West Ham United)
This was for me the toughest decision in the toss-up between Lingard and Antonio. I just edged towards Lingard due to his youth and his experience playing at high level European football. Antonio may well be selected because of his versatility, pace and skill, and I would most definitely not begrudge him of such an honour, but for me, just Lingard.
Jermain Defoe (A.F.C Bournemouth)
The wily 35 year old striker has the fitness and ability of an in-prime 27 year old, but his form of late just slots him behind Danny Welbeck in my opinion. Although a clinical finisher and extremely talented, he is getting on a little and this must be his last chance to play in a major tournament. If he scores 15 goals for Bournemouth this season I would definitely take him above Welbeck but I just think Welbeck brings something different to the other two strikers.
Daniel Sturridge (Liverpool F.C.)
Many people would take Daniel Sturridge above Welbeck and Vardy on his form of Liverpool's thrilling title attempt of 2013/14. But the typical Sturridge generalisations saying that he has quick pace and clinical finishing ability are, in my opinion, total myths. He hasn't shown any noticeably quick pace since that miraculous season, and his conversion rate has declined in serious force. Not only this, but his injury record is not one to be proud of either. Generally speaking, he's one not to get too excited about because he will just let you down, and I speak from experience. It's such a shame because for a man of such talent to be tossed off is an extreme disappointment, but it's just realism. He's had enough chances to stamp down his fitness and form and for me, this is the final straw.
I hope you enjoyed this, as it's taken over a week's effort for me to complete, and any informed views and criticism is extremely welcome in the comments!
Comments
Post a Comment